runitsjess (runitsjess) wrote in egl,

  • Location:

Twinkle Journey Comparison Post Review

 I have the 2010 Pinafore JSK in Navy and the 2015 Medium Length JSK in black, so I thought I would do a comparison post.

TJ re-release black pinafore JSK.jpg twinkle journey.jpg

Here's a full shot side by side:

no title

The two dresses differ vastly in a lot of ways, mostly in small details, which I will go into step by step.

HEM: Only the bottom ruffle is really different, Navy on the right has two layers, an underlayer with the printed fabric and a chiffon ruffle over that. Rerelease on left just has a chiffon ruffle added to hem.

no title

PRINT: The unicorn scene print running along the hem is about the same, besides the color. I noticed that even though the original is older, the unicorn scene looks crisper on it compared to the release. The rerelease colours look more faded out, and lines are not as sharp in the art.

no title
Black / Navy

WAIST TIES: The original has a chiffon ruffle running down middle from top to bottom, and a chiffon ruffle running along the bottom of the waist tie. It's attatched by two star buttons and uses the same printed fabric as the bodice.

Rerelease has no ruffles, but has the unicorn print at the bottom of the waist ties, and is attatched by regular round black buttons.

I wish Meta had used star buttons for the waist ties and shoulder straps for the 2015 release, I thought that was a really nice detail in the Navy dress.

no title

BODICE & SHOULDER STRAPS: Navy Pinafore JSK has 3 bodice bows, the largest bow comes with pearls sewn in. The Rerelease has four star buttons along the chest, chiffon ruffles lining the four buttons and one black chiffon bow (not included).

Where the skirt attatches to the bodice, it feels more gathered in the re release than the original. Rerelease dress also feels wider in the bust than the original.

Navy dress has 2 chiffon ruffles running along the bodice down the front, re release just has some small lace. There is a chiffon ruffle running along the neckline, straps, and back of the dress, re release does not have any.

The shoulder straps on the original are wider with chiffon ruffles lining the strap. Re release has mich thinner straps with no chiffon ruffle lining it, The lack of detail on the rerelease is stark compared to the original.

no title

Black / Navy

BACK OF BODICE: 2010 JSK had quarter shirring in the back, 2015 is all the way shirred in the back, which I feel is not as elegant of a look, but is great if you are looking to accomdate a wider bust size. You can also see where the Navy has 4 star buttons for the strap, while the Black has 2 round buttons.

no title

Basically I come away with this deciding that the 2010 JSK has much nicer details than the 2015 JSK. I can see why Meta was charging less for the re release, because it just doesn't have the same attention to details that the original did. The rerelease has a far more casual feel. I prefer the shape of the bodice of the original to the re release, along with the attention to detail with the star buttons and chiffon ruffles lining the dress. Both are beautiful though!

Tags: review product: dresses

  • Unreleased Items You Wish Were Released?

    I was looking through some of my old (ouch) AP catalogs and in one of them from 2014 there was this marshmallow bag pictured with the re-release of…

  • Question for brands/seamstresses/designers

    Hi everyone! Recently I’ve been looking more into how Lolita dresses are made, and I had no idea that some brands had designers separate from the…


    Looking for Indie/Small Lolita brands! Hi, I was wondering if there was a place I could look for small owned Lolita brands ! Especially US based ^^…

  • Post a new comment


    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded