honeyteaclover (honeyteaclover) wrote in egl,
honeyteaclover
honeyteaclover
egl

Ethical Consumerism and Lolita Fashion

In my everyday life, I'm one of those consumers who scrutinizes labels on every product in the grocery store. I try to be a conscientious shopper. I've started thinking a little more about my consumer choices when it comes to lolita clothing, and I thought I'd present a particular issue to the EGL community and gather your thoughts.

Recently, I've read gossip about some shopping services in Japan. I guess these shopping services are no longer satisfied charging the 8% or 10% fee to shop for you, and are looking for other ways to cash in... Their misconduct doesn't extend to the point of directly affecting the SS customers (they aren't scamming people, per se)--however, their business practices might still negatively affect others, and may eventually trickle-down to affect the rest of the lolita community.

I've heard accounts of shopping services that arrive at Closet Child during sales/releases, shove regular shoppers out of the way, grab stuff from other people, and carry off entire racks of dresses. They then take these dresses to online secondhand communities and resell them for double or triple the original price of the item at Closet Child. (In other words, they are scalpers.) The practice has gotten so bad that supposedly Closet Child is raising their prices in response to these secondhand scalpers.

Based on various clues, I've already seen several of these resellers on EGL comm sales as well as other sales communities (I see a bunch of dresses on the Closet Child blog--and the next week, notice that the same set of dresses are being sold on the sales comm for 2x or 3x the previous price). To add to the sketchiness, these resellers often pose as "normal girls living in Japan," but after looking through their profiles, it's clear that they are businesses that are pretending to be girls--and their targets are unaware foreigners, not people living in Japan. The prices are still somewhere within the reasonable budget for most lolitas shopping on the sales comm, so there's no issue with the resellers unloading much of their stock...but a part of me wants to say to the buyers: "Hey! You're being scalped! And potentially supporting a corrupt business!"

...So I wanted to ask:

- Is there anything technically "wrong" with what they're doing?
- Should the lolita community respond to this kind of behavior? (Or is it up to Closet Child/the mods/other authorities to monitor and stop this kind of thing?)
- If you found out that your shopping service/seller acquired your dress through unethical means, would you still purchase it?
- If you knew that a particular seller is a business that uses this practice (buying a secondhand dress with the specific intention of marking it up and selling it on the comm sales), would you still buy from them?
- On the comm sales, there's a rule against accusing others of scalping, and that people are allowed to set whatever price they want on items. However, should the same rule apply to businesses?
Tags: discussion: consumer ethics, discussion: social issues, ordering: shopping services, store: closet child
Subscribe

  • Unreleased Items You Wish Were Released?

    I was looking through some of my old (ouch) AP catalogs and in one of them from 2014 there was this marshmallow bag pictured with the re-release of…

  • Question for brands/seamstresses/designers

    Hi everyone! Recently I’ve been looking more into how Lolita dresses are made, and I had no idea that some brands had designers separate from the…

  • LF: INDIE LOLITA BRANDS

    Looking for Indie/Small Lolita brands! Hi, I was wondering if there was a place I could look for small owned Lolita brands ! Especially US based ^^…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 70 comments
Previous
← Ctrl ← Alt
Next
Ctrl → Alt →
Previous
← Ctrl ← Alt
Next
Ctrl → Alt →

  • Unreleased Items You Wish Were Released?

    I was looking through some of my old (ouch) AP catalogs and in one of them from 2014 there was this marshmallow bag pictured with the re-release of…

  • Question for brands/seamstresses/designers

    Hi everyone! Recently I’ve been looking more into how Lolita dresses are made, and I had no idea that some brands had designers separate from the…

  • LF: INDIE LOLITA BRANDS

    Looking for Indie/Small Lolita brands! Hi, I was wondering if there was a place I could look for small owned Lolita brands ! Especially US based ^^…