From Anthropologie (all classic style):
Peppermint Swirl Spectators
From ModCloth.com (classic, and sweet):
Unicorn Princess Heel (comes in other colours)
Heart Shoe Clips
From Urban Outfitters (gothic/punk and classic):
Wooden Architectural Wedge
Double Strap Mary Jane by 'who we see'
Studded Heel by Ecote
Punk Bootie by Deena & Ozzy
Fringe boot (ankle) by 'who we see'
Fringe boot (knee) by 'who we see'
Victorian Spectator Boot
Target (gothic and classic):
Dolce Vita for target pirate bootie
Classic Moreen Mary Jane
'Westerly' Oxford Bootie
From Naya via planetshoes.com (classic and maybe gothic):
'Jasper' Oxford Bootie
'Cara' rose mary jane
'Briar' Mary jane
anyways, i'll try and add more later. Looks like a good year to be a classic loli in the US right now for shoes tho!