Which kind of Pannier do you recommend???

I am thinking about purchaseing a new pannier for myself. However I am not sure which kind is good just by looking at pictures. If anyone have experience buying them please recommend a good one for me.

this bodyline one
http://item.rakuten.co.jp/bodyline/pan056/

the one from Maximam
http://www.maxicimam.com/?pid=42183534
http://www.maxicimam.com/?pid=31818188

I like the length of the BL one, but Im not sure if it is puffy enough.
Any ideas???